Why Incremental Risk Management Is Dead - And What’s Next

Healthcare cybersecurity is facing a crisis. Incremental risk management - adding small security improvements over time - can no longer keep up with the pace of modern threats. With cyberattacks on healthcare organizations increasing by 55% in 2024 and breaches impacting nearly 70% of the U.S. population, outdated strategies are leaving patient data and operations exposed. The financial impact is severe, with phishing-related breaches costing $9.77 million per incident on average.

To address these challenges, healthcare organizations must shift from reactive, step-by-step approaches to dynamic and forward-looking strategies. This includes:

• Continuous risk assessment: Identifying and addressing vulnerabilities in real time.
• Real-time monitoring: Detecting threats as they happen, not months later.
• Advanced tools: Platforms like Censinet RiskOps™ automate risk management, streamline vendor oversight, and improve response times.
• Employee training: Focused, role-specific education to reduce human error.
• Collaborative frameworks: Using standards like NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 and HITRUST CSF to guide efforts.

The stakes are high - stolen health records fetch up to 10 times more than credit card data, and healthcare breaches cost three times more per record compared to other industries. By prioritizing cybersecurity as a core part of patient safety, healthcare organizations can reduce risks, meet regulatory demands, and protect their operations.

Proactive Healthcare Cybersecurity for Today's Threat Landscape

Problems with Incremental Risk Management in Healthcare Today

Across the United States, healthcare organizations are realizing that their traditional step-by-step methods for managing cybersecurity risks are no longer effective. The landscape has shifted dramatically - threats are evolving faster, and regulatory demands are becoming more complex ^[1]. What once worked is now leaving systems vulnerable to attacks and compliance failures. Let’s dive into the key issues.

Problems with Reactive Strategies

One of the biggest flaws in reactive cybersecurity is its timing. These strategies only kick in after a breach, focusing on damage control rather than prevention ^[8]. This mindset reduces cybersecurity to just another compliance task, ignoring its critical role in safeguarding patient safety.

On average, cybercriminals remain undetected for 194 days before breaches are discovered ^[7]. During this time, attackers can freely explore systems, steal sensitive data, and establish backdoors. By the time the breach is identified, the damage is often catastrophic.

Organizations relying on reactive measures are also less likely to have automated processes or solid business continuity plans. This leaves them scrambling during an attack, without clear protocols or backup systems in place ^[8].

The 2024 attack on Change Healthcare is a stark example of these failures. The breach forced the company to shut down 111 services and pay a $22 million ransom ^[8]. Larger healthcare providers impacted by the attack reportedly lost over $100 million, with some resorting to loans just to stay operational ^[8]. The total cost of the incident is now estimated between $2.3 billion and $2.45 billion ^[11].

These shortcomings are compounded by broader systemic issues that make healthcare organizations even more vulnerable.

Main Challenges Healthcare Organizations Face

Healthcare systems are facing a perfect storm of vulnerabilities that outdated, incremental approaches cannot address. One major issue is the interconnected nature of the healthcare ecosystem. Hospitals, pharmacies, and specialty-care facilities are all linked, and weak oversight of the supply chain creates significant risks ^[5].

Third-party vendors are a growing problem. A staggering 90% of healthcare breaches are tied to vendors ^[8], yet many organizations still use outdated vendor management processes. For instance, the Episource breach in 2025 exposed over 5.4 million patient records, impacting multiple healthcare providers nationwide ^[6].

Legacy systems present another challenge. Many healthcare organizations rely on older technologies that lack modern security updates ^[1]. These systems were never designed to handle today’s cybersecurity threats, and patching them incrementally is like trying to fix a sinking ship with duct tape.

The numbers paint a grim picture: 92% of healthcare organizations experienced at least one cyberattack over a year, an 88% increase from 2023 ^[9]. Social engineering attacks are rampant as well, with 81% of organizations falling victim last year ^[4]. These attacks exploit human error, which incremental training programs often fail to address effectively.

Cloud misconfigurations add yet another layer of risk. In 2025, a major U.S. health insurance provider accidentally exposed 4.7 million customer records over three years due to a poorly configured cloud storage bucket ^[1]. Such incidents highlight the dangers of moving to the cloud without implementing strong security measures upfront.

Perhaps most troubling is the lack of proactive risk assessment. Shockingly, 40% of healthcare organizations do not actively evaluate their IT risks ^[4].

Regulatory and Compliance Pressure

In addition to operational vulnerabilities, healthcare organizations are under immense regulatory pressure. The sector is heavily regulated, and keeping up with constant updates significantly impacts costs and operations ^[12]. Organizations that try to address compliance issues incrementally often find themselves perpetually behind.

The financial toll of compliance is enormous. A typical community hospital with 161 beds spends nearly $7.6 million annually on administrative tasks related to federal regulations ^[14]. On average, every patient admission costs hospitals $1,200 in compliance-related expenses ^[14]. And as regulations evolve, these costs continue to rise.

Adapting internal policies to meet new standards is another challenge. Incremental changes often fail to keep pace with regulatory updates, leaving organizations in a constant state of catch-up ^[12]. Falling behind can lead to severe consequences, including fines, lawsuits, and reputational damage ^[12][13].

The numbers are staggering: healthcare data breaches in April 2025 alone rose by 17.9% from the previous month, affecting over 10.26 million individuals ^[12].

Telehealth regulations provide a clear example of these challenges. As telehealth has shifted from a secondary option to a primary healthcare solution, new regulations have emerged to address this change ^[13]. Organizations that relied on incremental approaches to secure telehealth systems found themselves scrambling to meet compliance requirements while trying to maintain patient care.

The regulatory environment demands constant monitoring and quick adjustments. Yet, incremental methods, which rely on periodic assessments and slow improvements, are simply not up to the task. The gap between what regulators expect and what organizations can deliver continues to grow, creating a compliance crisis that cannot be solved with outdated risk management strategies ^[12].

Modern Strategies and Frameworks for Proactive Risk Management

Healthcare organizations are moving away from the old "wait-and-see" approach to a more forward-thinking model that anticipates threats and strengthens their operations. This shift is paving the way for detailed strategies and frameworks aimed at improving cybersecurity readiness.

Instead of slow, step-by-step improvements, these proactive methods tackle the weaknesses of reactive models head-on.

Proactive Risk Management Models

At the heart of modern cybersecurity is continuous risk assessment, replacing the outdated practice of periodic reviews. This proactive mindset focuses on anticipating issues before they occur, adjusting to new threats, and addressing vulnerabilities as they emerge ^[8]. It emphasizes that secure IT systems are not just a compliance checkbox but are critical to an organization's mission ^[8].

A key component of this approach is real-time monitoring, which offers around-the-clock visibility into networks, applications, and data flows. This enables organizations to detect unusual activity immediately, rather than discovering breaches months after the fact. With flexible response frameworks, teams can tailor their actions to the specifics of each threat.

Proactive cybersecurity strategies include several essential elements:

• Ongoing security risk assessments
• Comprehensive third-party risk management
• Automation and process optimization
• Continuous workforce training ^[8]

These components work together to create a dynamic and adaptive security posture.

One of the most critical areas is employee training, as human error accounts for over 80% of breaches ^[8]. Organizations are now implementing role-specific training programs to cover essentials like password security, recognizing phishing attempts, and handling sensitive data safely ^[3].

"The cyber bad guys spend every waking moment thinking about how to compromise your cybersecurity procedures and controls", warns John Riggi, Senior Advisor for Cybersecurity and Risk at the American Hospital Association ^[2].

Using Leading Industry Frameworks

To guide the transition from reactive to proactive risk management, healthcare organizations are relying on established frameworks. One standout is the NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0, which provides a structured approach to identifying, protecting, detecting, responding to, and recovering from cybersecurity incidents ^[15].

Another valuable resource is the HITRUST Common Security Framework (CSF). Unlike HIPAA, which is a legal requirement, HITRUST offers measurable standards and objectives for implementing the administrative, technical, and physical safeguards mandated by HIPAA ^[16]. HITRUST integrates elements from ISO, NIST, PCI, and HIPAA, making it a comprehensive tool for healthcare organizations.

HITRUST also tailors its assessments based on the complexity and risk profile of an organization. Repeat users of this framework have seen a 54% reduction in corrective actions during subsequent assessments ^[17]. Best practices for implementation include evaluating current measures and creating customized plans that align with specific risks and operational needs ^[15].

Further guidance comes from the HHS Healthcare Cybersecurity Goals, which focus on safeguarding patient data while maintaining the availability of critical systems needed for patient care.

These frameworks not only streamline risk assessments but also encourage collaboration across departments, fostering a unified approach to cybersecurity.

The Role of Collaborative Governance

Effective risk management requires breaking down silos. Collaboration among IT, clinical, and administrative leaders is vital for building robust cybersecurity practices ^[3]. This teamwork allows for real-time identification and mitigation of risks while ensuring that security measures integrate seamlessly into clinical workflows ^[18].

"A progressive approach must involve collaboration between information technology, clinical, and administrative leaders to be successful", explains Dr. Matthew Clarke ^[3].

Practical steps for collaboration include involving IT teams during the procurement of new devices to ensure they align with cybersecurity plans and providing clinicians with specialized training on security risks relevant to their roles ^[3]. Establishing clear communication channels to share updates on emerging threats and best practices is equally important.

Leadership plays a crucial role in fostering a culture of security. Incentive programs that reward good cybersecurity practices can motivate both IT staff and clinicians to stay engaged in security efforts ^[3]. Regular audits, vulnerability assessments, and penetration testing - conducted with input from all departments - help ensure that protective measures are effective across the board.

The goal is to create an environment where security becomes a natural part of daily routines and decision-making. While achieving this shift demands consistent effort from leadership at all levels, it is essential for building the kind of cybersecurity resilience that modern healthcare organizations need to thrive.

sbb-itb-535baee

New Tools and Technologies for Next-Generation Risk Management

Modern challenges in healthcare cybersecurity demand more than incremental updates - they call for tools that integrate automation, AI, and collaborative workflows. These next-generation platforms provide the flexibility and capabilities needed to address today’s dynamic threats, moving beyond outdated methods to ensure a more comprehensive approach to risk management.

Censinet RiskOps™: A Comprehensive Solution

Censinet RiskOps™ brings together risk management across vendors, patient data, medical devices, and supply chains, creating a collaborative network between healthcare organizations and third-party vendors ^[19].

The impact of this approach is clear. Tower Health, for example, saw major improvements in efficiency after adopting Censinet RiskOps™. Terry Grogan, CISO at Tower Health, highlighted how the platform transformed their operations:

"Censinet RiskOps allowed 3 FTEs to go back to their real jobs!" – Terry Grogan, CISO, Tower Health ^[19]

The system replaces inconsistent custom assessments with standardized questionnaires, while automated corrective action plans ensure risks are addressed methodically ^[25]. Real-time risk scoring offers immediate insights into an organization’s risk status, and breach alerts enable rapid responses to emerging threats.

Baptist Health also benefited from the platform’s collaborative features. James Case, VP & CISO, shared how it streamlined processes and fostered connections within the healthcare community:

"Not only did we get rid of spreadsheets, but we have that larger community [of hospitals] to partner and work with." – James Case, VP & CISO, Baptist Health ^[19]

In addition to unifying risk management, AI-driven automation further enhances efficiency and responsiveness.

AI-Driven Automation for Improved Efficiency

Artificial intelligence is reshaping healthcare cybersecurity by offering capabilities that go well beyond traditional security tools. For instance, Censinet AITM speeds up third-party risk assessments by allowing vendors to complete security questionnaires in seconds. It also automatically summarizes vendor documentation and generates detailed risk reports based on assessment data.

AI systems excel at analyzing vast datasets, identifying anomalies, and immediately isolating compromised systems. This real-time detection helps prevent ransomware attacks, unauthorized access, and other suspicious activities ^[20]. Unlike conventional tools that rely on known attack patterns, AI’s ability to detect unfamiliar threats makes it particularly effective in combating the evolving tactics of cybercriminals ^[21].

Additionally, AI aids in prioritizing vulnerabilities, enabling healthcare organizations to focus their resources on the most critical risks ^[22]. Its behavioral analytics can also identify potential insider threats by flagging unusual user activity patterns.

Given the rising stakes - healthcare data breaches cost an average of $10.9 million in 2023, and ransomware attacks have nearly doubled since 2022 ^[23] - AI-driven tools are becoming indispensable. These technologies address the delays and reactive shortcomings that have long hindered traditional risk management methods.

Simplifying Governance and Compliance

Modern risk management platforms simplify the maze of governance, risk, and compliance (GRC) tasks that healthcare organizations face. Censinet RiskOps™ centralizes policies, risks, and tasks related to AI, automatically routing key findings to the appropriate stakeholders for review.

Advanced routing ensures that critical assessment results reach the right people, such as AI governance committees, without delays. This structured approach reduces communication gaps common in traditional compliance workflows.

Real-time data aggregation, presented in intuitive dashboards, provides continuous insights into compliance status and overall risk levels. This immediate access helps organizations stay aligned with regulatory requirements like HIPAA, HITRUST, and NIST frameworks.

Automation also streamlines recurring compliance tasks, such as sending assessment questionnaires, collecting evidence, and tracking remediation efforts ^[24]. For healthcare organizations managing numerous vendors and complex supply chains, these standardized processes ensure consistency in evaluating third-party risks.

Crucially, while automation handles routine tasks, human oversight remains integral. Configurable rules and review processes ensure that experienced risk teams retain control over critical decisions. This balance between automation and human expertise eliminates the inefficiencies of manual processes while preserving the strategic judgment needed for effective cybersecurity governance. By combining speed and oversight, these platforms provide a smarter way to manage the complex landscape of healthcare cybersecurity.

Steps for Moving to a Resilient Risk Management Model

Shifting from a reactive approach to a proactive risk management model isn't just a minor adjustment - it requires a complete overhaul of how risks are identified, assessed, and managed across your organization. This transformation is especially critical for healthcare organizations, where outdated methods can leave vulnerabilities unchecked. Instead of merely patching flaws, the focus must be on building a system that anticipates and addresses risks before they escalate.

MIT Sloan Professor Retsef Levi sums it up perfectly:

"Resiliency is the moment when your company is punched in the mouth - it's about how prepared you are for that moment and how well you can recover." ^[27]

Preparation begins by taking stock of your current capabilities, then implementing advanced solutions and fostering a culture that prioritizes proactive risk management.

Checking Your Current Risk Management Maturity

Before diving into new solutions, it's important to assess where your organization currently stands. Conducting a structured maturity assessment can reveal gaps and highlight areas for improvement. Using frameworks like ISO 31000 and COSO ERM, you can define your enterprise risk management (ERM) vision and evaluate performance and risk indicators that align with your organization's risk appetite ^[28].

Risk management maturity models provide a roadmap, showing how organizations typically progress through stages - from initial and reactive to managed and optimized practices ^[29]. By identifying where your current processes fall short, you can shift from reactive measures to a more strategic, forward-thinking approach.

Setting Up Advanced Risk Management Solutions

Once you've assessed your risk management maturity, the next step is upgrading your tools and processes. Replace outdated spreadsheets and manual tracking with comprehensive digital platforms that centralize risk management. Advanced solutions like Censinet RiskOps™ streamline processes by integrating workflows, automating assessments, and providing real-time insights. These platforms ensure a consistent evaluation of third-party vendors, patient data, medical devices, and supply chains, using standardized questionnaires instead of inconsistent custom assessments.

Features like real-time risk scoring, automated corrective action plans, and breach alerts provide the agility needed to respond to emerging threats. To support the transition, invest in targeted training and establish a system for continuous monitoring and stakeholder feedback ^[29].

Building a Culture of Proactive Risk Ownership

While technology plays a crucial role, it’s not enough on its own. A resilient risk management model depends on cultivating a culture where every team member takes ownership of risk identification and mitigation. This means empowering staff at all levels - not just those in traditional risk management roles - to voice concerns and take proactive steps to address potential issues.

Leadership must set the tone by embedding risk awareness into the organization's culture. Clear expectations, adequate resources, and ongoing training programs are essential. Encourage employees to ask "what if" questions, report concerns, and think critically about potential vulnerabilities. Regular education and active listening practices help ensure the entire organization stays prepared for new challenges ^[30].

Cross-departmental collaboration is key to this cultural shift. When everyone embraces the mindset of "See something, say something," the organization becomes better equipped to handle evolving risks, from cybersecurity threats to operational disruptions. For healthcare organizations, building this resilience not only addresses risks more effectively but also supports smoother patient care and long-term growth ^[26].

Conclusion: Building Resilience in Healthcare Cybersecurity

The days of incremental risk management are behind us - it simply can't keep up with the fast-paced and ever-changing cybersecurity threats facing healthcare today ^[34]. In 2023 alone, cyberattacks on the healthcare sector surged by a staggering 128%, underscoring the urgency for a more robust approach ^[34].

Healthcare organizations are under immense financial and operational strain. With unsafe care contributing to over 3 million preventable deaths each year, the stakes are life and death. Proactive measures not only save lives but also have the potential to reduce medical costs by $25–$31.5 billion annually ^[33][32].

To truly safeguard patient safety, healthcare organizations must embrace proactive risk management. This involves conducting in-depth risk assessments, leveraging advanced technologies, and fostering a culture of accountability ^[10]. Shifting from reactive to proactive strategies enables organizations to address vulnerabilities before they escalate into critical issues, ensuring both patient safety and operational stability.

Tools like Censinet RiskOps™ play a crucial role by automating risk assessments, streamlining vendor management, and providing real-time threat intelligence. These platforms empower organizations to act swiftly and effectively, mitigating risks before they become major incidents ^[10].

However, technology alone isn't enough. A meaningful transformation requires a cultural shift where cybersecurity becomes everyone's responsibility. Every team member must be equipped to recognize threats and follow clear protocols for reporting and response ^[35].

The regulatory environment is also tightening. For instance, the Health Infrastructure Security and Accountability Act now mandates the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) to establish minimum cybersecurity standards for healthcare providers ^[34]. Organizations that proactively adopt these practices will not only comply with emerging regulations but also position themselves as leaders in patient safety and care quality.

By embracing proactive risk management, healthcare organizations can achieve far-reaching benefits. Beyond strengthening cybersecurity, this approach enhances patient safety, improves the quality of care, and fosters trust among patients, partners, and regulators ^[10][31].

As cybersecurity threats continue to evolve, the path forward is clear: lead with a comprehensive and proactive strategy to protect patient safety and ensure the highest standards of care.

FAQs

What’s the difference between incremental and proactive risk management in healthcare cybersecurity?

Incremental risk management takes a reactive stance, dealing with risks only after they’ve materialized. The focus here is on damage control and recovery efforts. On the other hand, proactive risk management is all about staying ahead of the curve. This approach prioritizes identifying risks early, maintaining ongoing monitoring, and putting safeguards in place to minimize vulnerabilities.

This proactive mindset is especially important in healthcare cybersecurity. With threats constantly evolving, it’s crucial for organizations to anticipate potential breaches. By moving from reactive measures to a proactive strategy, healthcare providers can strengthen their defenses and better protect against new and emerging risks.

What are the best ways for healthcare organizations to implement real-time monitoring and continuous risk assessment?

Healthcare organizations can strengthen their defenses by adopting automated risk management tools that offer continuous monitoring of threats and vulnerabilities. These tools work around the clock, identifying risks as they arise, which enables quicker responses and reduces the likelihood of significant damage.

Another powerful approach is leveraging predictive analytics. By examining patterns and trends, organizations can foresee potential risks and address them before they escalate. Pairing this with centralized dashboards gives teams real-time visibility into risks, offering a clear and consolidated view of their security landscape.

When used together, these strategies allow healthcare organizations to shift from a reactive stance to a proactive risk management model, better prepared to navigate today’s cybersecurity complexities.

How do frameworks like NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 and HITRUST CSF help strengthen cybersecurity in healthcare?

Frameworks like the NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 and HITRUST CSF are essential for strengthening cybersecurity in healthcare. They provide structured methods to identify, evaluate, and address cybersecurity risks while ensuring alignment with industry standards and regulatory guidelines.

These tools also make compliance more manageable, improve operational resilience, and offer a step-by-step guide for implementing strong security practices. With these frameworks, healthcare organizations can safeguard sensitive patient information, uphold trust, and proactively address emerging cyber threats.

Related posts

• From Reactive to Threat Intelligence-Driven Cybersecurity
• Building Vendor Risk Frameworks for Healthcare IT
• 5 Challenges in Healthcare Cyber Risk Management
• From Reactive to Proactive: How Modern Risk Assessors Are Transforming Organizational Resilience